Skip to content
OmegadiceWorld

Universes Beyond is negatively impacting Magic: The Gathering's top game mode, however there’s a straightforward fix.

Commander could be the most favored way to enjoy Magic: The Gathering, however, in my card-buying funds, there is nothing that matches a draft. Be it when you head to your local game store on a Friday night or assemble with your playgroup, few things rival the experience of ripping open a handful of boosters and quickly assembling a limited deck for a speedy Magic: The Gathering tournament.

The draft format equalizes the field of play (it's impossible to purchase an advantage against your opponents to secure victory), and moreover, you leave with a bunch of new cards to incorporate into your Commander collections. Nonetheless, there’s a escalating issue in the draft format (and in MTG's other limited play mode, sealed deck) that’s only worsening as Wizards of the Coast and its corporate owner continue to ramp up crossover sets. The core issue is two words: the legend rule.

Understanding the Legendary Creature Issue

MTG’s three-decade past is filled with fantasy and science fiction beings, from archetypal staples like goblins and elves and iconic original races like eldrazi and phyrexians. A significantly narrower portion of those creatures is legendary, which means that instead of standing for an whole group of creatures, the individual card depicts a unique character in the Magic universe.

The classification of being legendary also has a a number of mechanical effects in the game. For one thing, legendary creatures are typically more powerful and rare than their regular counterparts, though that’s shifted in modern design. Then there's the aforementioned legendary rule, which clearly says: If two or more legendary permanents with the same name are controlled by the same player, that player chooses one of them, and the rest are put into their owners' graveyards.

This implies you are unable to play two of the identical legendary creature at the same time, or create a copy (unless you have a specific exception). This doesn’t matter much in Commander/EDH, where constructed decks are restricted to one copy of each card, but in limited draft, where there are no such limits, it’s far more impactful.

How Universes Beyond Phenomenon Amplifies the Problem

Until recently, this posed little difficulty. The majority of Magic sets employ legendary creatures sparingly, especially when it comes to common and uncommon cards. However, with Universes Beyond, this is no longer the case. The recent Spider-Man set was loaded with them, with a large percentage of the creatures being legendary-designated, encompassing a notable fraction of the common creatures. Magic’s latest crossover expansion, TMNT, is no different, and it seems likely that other future Universes Beyond sets like Marvel and Star Trek will emulate this approach.

This causes an clear issue in draft and sealed formats where the tried-and-true tactic is frequently to create a reliable deck by selecting as many of the copies of a card as you can. In a Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles draft, you would be persuaded to draft several copies of a powerful turtle since it synergizes well with itself, but you’ll ultimately only have in play one at a time because of the legend rule.

The Simple Fix

In a recent commentary, the game’s head designer, addressed this criticism directly. The biggest advantage is more people get to open up a pack with a card of their favorite character,” he wrote.

To some extent, this is understandable. Inevitably, the aim of crossovers is to incorporate beloved stories into Magic, and playing with the characters from those universes is a key part of that appeal. Yet, a great many of these intellectual properties also lack a extensive list of unnamed characters to pick from, which is the reason you wind up with forgettable cards in these sets. There frequently aren't enough non-legendary creative choices to sustain a full set of Magic cards.

In the aforementioned blog post, it was also noted that there have been efforts to “get rid of the drawback (without success) for years.”

So, it could be time to pull the trigger and remove the legend rule — not for all of the game, but for limited formats, only. Ultimately, draft decks already differ from other constructed formats by letting you include as many duplicates of a card as you draft; other competitive formats restrict you to four copies per card. Suspending the legend rule in this specific case solves the core problem with minimal significant negative consequences (the likelihood of someone drafting two copies of an mythic rare legendary creature are slim).

This straightforward adjustment could preserve Magic: The Gathering the draft experience. Of course, another option would be to just discontinue Universes Beyond altogether. That would also resolve the problem, too. Until such a drastic measure is taken, abolishing the legendary rule for a few specific formats would solve the immediate problem.

Written by

Ronald Bell

Avid tabletop gamer and dice collector with 10 years of RPG experience.

OmegadiceWorld

Type to search articles.